better dead than red

Okay, I admit I have as many issues with Michael Moore as the next guy. He has an unpleasant personality, he can rely on a mind-numbing slamming of his message home over and over, he uses tactics that are corny and, well, over played and melodramatic. In Sicko, his display in front of Guantanamo Bay was as irrational and silly as when he put the photograph of the murdered girl on Chuckie Heston’s driveway, lame and ill thought-out attempts at making some kind of emotional statement directed at the absurdly incorrect people…. But through all the hogwash and humor, his message is a strong one, a message that has remained the same message through his career. No matter what the subject matter of the movie (or his seeming obsession with Canada or his “anti-Americanism”), when you get down to it, they all have one focus. Which is that in this country, it is acceptable and expected for organizations to pursue profit above all else, with little (if any) concern for anyone else. And, of course, this message doesn’t really mean much unless it is packaged with examples showing that things don’t have to be like this. All of this really comes to the forefront in his newest, Sicko. Like most of his movies, watching how things work here and then how things work in the rest of the DemoCapitalistic first world makes one feel gullible and lame to be an American and to not be either leaving or actually changing things here.

Sicko is the story of how the US medical system has no concern with making anyone better, instead it is all consumed with profit. In fact, the public is stuck between a two-way battle for profits! From the HMO’s side, doing the most billable treatment with the least effort (in cahoots with the pharmaceutical companies who want to sell as many overpriced and unneeded drugs to everyone, even if it kills them and even if they don’t need them) and, from the insurances companies side, finding any excuse to pay for as little treatment as possible, even if it leads to the death of your patients. Unlike Moore and a lot of other people, I don’t really blame the insurance and health companies for this. The American obsession with profit, wealth and power coupled with politicians who are paid by big business to do their billing, and, well, what else would you expect. Our view of business and the strange fear of anything that could be misconstrued as socialism is the reason that this stuff happens. There would need to be an enormous shift in the way that the people in this country think and act before any of this stuff will improve. But watching Moore’s movies and seeing how other countries do things, it is a bit wrenching how everyone and everything is sold out for profits under a big blanket of lies. The most intriguing part of the film was the tape recording of President Nixon when he bascially approved changing the American medical system to an all-profit, minimal treatment system. Great. I would say that it all makes me want to emigrate to another country, but I’ve always wanted to do that anyway. New Zealand anyone?

Yes, regardless of what you might say about his ethics, or the particular examples that he uses of situations that he takes advantage of, he has a well-documented and pretty obvious point that communities and people in this country mean little to the powers that be except for their role as a profit-base to organize their methods around. It was a telling point that the old Member of Parliament made when he said that “keeping people poor makes them hopeless and when people are hopeless, they don’t vote. It the people would vote for someone who actually supported them, it would be an economic revolution”

And then, a fellow at work turned me onto this site (yes, another quiz) Glassboth.org, where you enter your views on various issues and they show you which presidential candidate you are the most similar to. I ended up with someone that I hadn’t even heard of… Mike Gravel… But after looking into his shtick (sadly, on youtube), I do think he’s a pretty good guy, even if he is a democrat.

How you compare

 

  • 1 Mike Gravel 93% similarity
  • 2 Dennis Kucinich 90% similarity
  • 3 Christopher Dodd 81% similarity
  • Mike Gravel shares a 93% similarity with your beliefs

    former Senator, (D-AK)

    Mike Gravel was born on May 13, 1930. He is a Democrat from Alaska. He served the state of Alaska as a Senator in the U.S. Senate from 1969 to 1981. He is primarily known for his efforts in ending the draft following the Vietnam War. While a Senator, Gravel spoke the Pentagon Papers into public record.

    Register to Vote: Rock the Vote, powered by Working Assets Wireless
    Social Security very similar find out why
    Taxes and Budget very similar find out why
    Abortion and Birth Control very similar find out why
    Iraq and Foreign Policy very similar find out why
    Trade and Economics very similar find out why
    Health Care very similar find out why
    Civil Liberties and Domestic Security very similar find out why
    Environment and Energy very similar find out why
    Education very similar find out why
    Gun Control similar find out why

     


4 Responses to “better dead than red”

  1. Kurty on December 22, 2007 14:08

    Inneresting!
    I got 88% Kucinich, 81% Edwards (!?) and 80% Gravel …

  2. Ashley on December 22, 2007 16:28

    Edwards? I will grant you that he is much more human-like than Al Gore, but he is still too shiny.

    I wonder what one would have to do to end up with Rudy “9/11? I was there, vote for me!” G?

  3. Kurty on December 23, 2007 14:52

    I think you’d have to cheat on your wife, make your constituents pay for it, make them pay for a cop to shoot a bum for no reason and generally make a deal with satan …
    You and Cait working monday? Will one or all be at Tandem?

  4. Ashley on December 23, 2007 16:44

    Cait should be there, I’ll be working in my little cubical.